Best Cheese for Turkey Sandwich: The Ultimate Guide

April 11, 2023

Best Cheese For Turkey Sandwich

Whether you’re packing a lunch for work or making a quick dinner, turkey sandwiches are always a crowd-pleaser. But, one thing that can really take your sandwich from ordinary to extraordinary is the cheese! There’s an array of options when it comes to cheese and it can be hard to choose the right one. That’s why we’ve put together this guide on the best cheeses for turkey sandwiches.

From classic American cheese slices to robust Provolone and creamy goat cheese, there’s something for everyone! Each cheese adds its own unique flavor profile and texture that will bring your sandwich to life. Not only will you have an unbeatable combination of flavors, but you’ll also have a delicious meal that looks as good as it tastes.

So, if you’re ready to give your turkey sandwich an upgrade, keep reading for the best cheeses for this classic sandwich!

What Is The Best Cheese For A Turkey Sandwich?

When it comes to making a turkey sandwich, the cheese you choose can make or break the entire experience. From mild cheddar to sharp Swiss, there are lots of options when it comes to finding the best cheese for a turkey sandwich. So what should you go with? Let’s explore some of the most popular choices.

One of the most iconic cheeses for turkey sandwiches is cheddar. This semi-hard cheese has a sharp flavor and goes great with any type of bread. It melts easily, making it a good choice if you want something nice and gooey on your sandwich. Cheddar also pairs well with other ingredients like lettuce, tomato, and bacon.

Another classic option for turkey sandwiches is Swiss cheese. Swiss is a milder cheese than cheddar but still packs a punch in terms of flavor. It adds creaminess to your sandwich and complements other flavors such as mustard and pickles very nicely. Swiss also melts nicely, so if you’re looking for melty goodness on your sandwich then this may be the way to go!

If you’re looking for something different, then provolone could be an interesting choice for your turkey sandwich. Provolone has an intense flavor that helps bring out all the other flavors in the dish – from sweet to savory – while still being creamy and smooth in texture. Plus it won’t overwhelm the other ingredients on your sandwich either!

When it comes down to choosing which cheese is best for your turkey sandwich, there are plenty of options available depending on what type of flavor profile you’re going for. For classic flavor combinations like cheddar or Swiss or something more unique like provolone, there’s sure to be something out there that will please even the pickiest eaters!

The Different Types Of Cheese For Turkey Sandwiches

When it comes to making a turkey sandwich, there’s no one-size-fits-all cheese. Different types of cheese bring different flavors and textures to the sandwich that can enhance your experience. From sharp cheddar to creamy brie, here are some of the best cheeses for a turkey sandwich.

First up is cheddar cheese. It’s a classic choice for sandwiches, and with good reason! Cheddar has a sharp flavor that pairs well with the savory notes of turkey. Plus, it adds a nice crunchy texture which complements the softness of the bread. If you’re looking for an extra cheesy option, look no further than extra sharp cheddar.

Another great option is Swiss cheese. It’s mild but still flavorful and adds just enough saltiness to balance out the sweetness of other ingredients like tomatoes or honey mustard. Swiss also has an interesting nutty flavor that makes it stand out from other cheeses on the sandwich.

Finally, there’s brie cheese which is a softer, creamier cheese that melts easily in your mouth. Its delicate flavor won’t overpower the other ingredients but still adds delicious creaminess to your sandwich. Brie also pairs well with vegetables like lettuce or tomatoes which can add freshness and crunch to your meal.

No matter what type of cheese you choose for your turkey sandwich, you’ll be sure to have a delicious meal! With so many options available, you can experiment with different flavors until you find the perfect combination for your own unique taste.

Cheddar Cheese

When it comes to the best cheese for turkey sandwiches, cheddar is a classic choice. Not only does it have a mild, creamy flavor that pairs well with turkey, but its texture is also ideal for adding extra crunch to a sandwich. Plus, this type of cheese comes in many varieties: from sharp and aged cheddars to white and yellow versions.

For those looking for something a bit more flavorful than plain cheddar cheese, there are several options to consider. Smoked cheddar has a slightly smoky flavor that gives the sandwich an added layer of complexity. Or try adding some extra zing with a jalapeno or pepper jack cheddar. These cheeses offer just enough heat to make the sandwich stand out without overpowering it.

No matter which type you choose, cheddar cheese is sure to add an extra level of deliciousness to your turkey sandwich. Its versatility makes it easy to customize and its flavor pairs perfectly with other ingredients like bacon or tomatoes. So next time you’re crafting your favorite sandwich, don’t forget about the power of cheddar!

Swiss Cheese

Swiss cheese is a creamy and slightly nutty cheese that pairs perfectly with turkey sandwiches. It is a semi-hard cheese with a mild flavor, making it an excellent option for those who don’t prefer strong cheeses. Swiss cheese has been used to make sandwiches for centuries, as its medium-strength flavor adds just the right amount of saltiness.

When deciding which type of cheese to use on your sandwich, it’s important to consider texture as well as flavor. Swiss cheese melts beautifully between two slices of bread, adding a creamy layer and helping hold all the different ingredients together. It also has small holes throughout, which provide an interesting visual element to the sandwich.

Using swiss cheese can add a great deal of flavor and texture to your turkey sandwich without overwhelming it. The mild taste will complement other vegetables and condiments like lettuce, tomato, onions and mustard. Plus, you’ll get a good dose of protein and calcium from this delicious cheese!

Mozzarella Cheese

Mozzarella cheese is a great option for turkey sandwiches. It’s one of the most popular types of cheese, thanks to its mild flavor and creamy texture. Plus, it melts easily, giving the sandwich a gooey layer of goodness.

When selecting mozzarella cheese for a turkey sandwich, look for freshness. Freshly-made mozzarella has a unique taste that can’t be found in pre-packaged slices – it adds an extra punch of flavor that really enhances the sandwich. Additionally, make sure to opt for full-fat mozzarella rather than low-fat or skim varieties; they tend to have a much better flavor and texture when melted.

So if you’re looking for a delicious cheesy topping for your turkey sandwich, consider trying mozzarella! Its mild flavor and creamy texture stands out from other cheeses, and its ease of melting makes it ideal for sandwiches. Give it a try – you won’t be disappointed!

Provolone Cheese

Provolone cheese is a great addition to a turkey sandwich. It has a rich, savory flavor that pairs well with the mildness of the turkey. Plus, it melts nicely and gives the sandwich an extra boost of texture.

If you want to make your turkey sandwich stand out from others, provolone cheese is the way to go. It’s semi-soft and has a slight nutty taste that will give your sandwich an extra kick. This type of cheese also has a slightly tangy taste that goes very well with more traditional condiments like mayonnaise and mustard.

When using provolone cheese for your sandwiches, be sure to slice it thin so that it doesn’t overpower the other ingredients in the sandwich. Additionally, you can opt for smoked provolone if you’d like an even richer flavor profile. Whether you choose regular or smoked provolone, it’s sure to make your turkey sandwich unique and delicious!

To sum up, provolone cheese adds depth to the flavor of a turkey sandwich while still remaining subtle enough not to overpower other ingredients. Its firm yet creamy consistency makes it ideal for melting onto sandwiches as well as adding an extra layer of texture and flavor. With its unique taste profile, it’s no wonder why provolone has become such a popular choice for sandwiches!

Pepper Jack Cheese

Pepper Jack cheese is a great addition to any turkey sandwich. It’s a flavorful, spicy alternative to the more traditional cheeses that would usually be used. Its melting properties make it an ideal candidate for pairing with turkey and other sandwich ingredients.

The pepper jack cheese adds a nice kick of spice to the sandwich, while also providing an element of creaminess. The flavor of the cheese blends well with the other ingredients in the sandwich, creating a delicious combination that can’t be beat. Plus, it provides a nice contrast to the milder flavors of turkey and other toppings.

In addition to its flavor profile, pepper jack cheese has some practical benefits too. It melts perfectly when grilled or heated up on the stove top, making it easy to add to any type of sandwich. Its texture is also just right for adding a bit of crunch without being too heavy or overwhelming. All these factors make pepper jack cheese a great choice for your next turkey sandwich!

Gouda Cheese

Gouda cheese is a great option for a turkey sandwich. Not only does it offer a creamy, nutty flavor that complements the turkey, but also its semi-hard texture adds a nice crunch to the overall sandwich experience. Its mild flavor makes it versatile enough to pair with other ingredients like tomatoes, lettuce, and onions.

Gouda cheese is an ideal choice not just for sandwiches, but also as an addition to salads or omelets. Its taste and texture are especially well suited for savory dishes like these. As such, it can be used as a substitute for cheddar cheese when preparing quesadillas or grilled cheese sandwiches. Plus, its meltability allows for easy incorporation into recipes that require melted cheese.

In short, gouda is an excellent addition to any meal requiring melted or semi-hard cheeses. Its flavor and texture make it the perfect companion for turkey sandwiches and other dishes alike – one that will certainly please any palate!

Sargento, Provolone Natural Cheese Slices, 8 oz, 12 count (Pack of 1)
  • Sargento Provolone Natural Cheese Slices bring a little taste of Italy right to your dining room table, whether it's for a romantic meal for two or a game day get together.
  • This 8 oz. package comes with 12 slices of Provolone cheese perfect for appetizers, entrees, and grilled cheese sandwiches.
  • 100% Real, Natural Cheese uses ingredients like, cultured pasteurized milk, salt, and enzymes.
  • Easy-close FreshLock packaging helps keep cheese fresh longer, but use within five days upon opening for maximum freshness
  • Our Family’s Passion Is Cheese
Sargento Swiss Natural Cheese SlicesGreat pairing with fruit and perfect for sandwiches, 7 Oz
  • The mellow, nutty flavor of Sargento Swiss cheese slices comes in a range of sharpness to lend a tangy note to turkey or reuben sandwiches, hamburgers, wraps and the ultimate BLT.
  • This 7 oz. package comes with 11 slices of Swiss cheese perfect for appetizers, entrees, and grilled cheese sandwiches.
  • 100% Real, Natural Cheese uses simple ingredients like, cultured pasteurized milk, salt, enzymes, and annatto - a plant-derived color.
  • Easy-open and -close Fresh-lock packaging keeps cheese at optimal freshness, but use within five days upon opening for maximum freshness.

How To Select The Best Cheese For A Turkey Sandwich

When it comes to selecting the best cheese for a turkey sandwich, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. The best cheese for your sandwich will depend on factors like personal preference and the type of sandwich you’re making. Whether you’re looking for something creamy, savory, or sharp, there are plenty of options to choose from.

If you’re after something creamy, brie is an excellent choice. Its soft texture pairs beautifully with the smoky flavor of turkey and its mild flavor won’t overpower other ingredients in your sandwich. Cheddar is another popular option; its sharp taste complements the savory notes of your turkey while adding a bit of crunch to your sandwich.

Alternatively, if you’d prefer something more savory, gouda or gruyere are both great options. Their nutty flavors are perfect for adding complexity to a classic turkey sandwich and they also pair well with other ingredients like mustard and pickles. For those looking for something sharper, blue cheese is a great choice. Its strong flavor adds depth to any dish and its creamy texture adds richness to any sandwich.

Ultimately, when it comes to selecting the best cheese for your turkey sandwich, it really just depends on what kind of flavor profile you’d like to achieve and what tastes best to you! Experiment with different cheeses until you find one that works perfectly with your favorite sandwich recipe.

Tips For Making The Perfect Turkey Sandwich With Cheese

Tips For Making The Perfect Turkey Sandwich With Cheese

When making a turkey sandwich, cheese can take it to the next level. But with so many types of cheese available, how do you know which one is best? To help you make the perfect turkey sandwich with cheese, here are some tips to consider.

First, think about the flavor and texture of your cheese. Is it sharp and tangy? Creamy and smooth? Aged and crumbly? There are many types of cheeses for all kinds of tastes. Choose one that pairs well with the other ingredients in your sandwich and complements the flavor of the turkey.

Another factor to keep in mind is how much fat content is in the cheese. While some cheeses are high in saturated fat, there are also low-fat versions available. If you prefer a cheesy but light sandwich, opt for a lower-fat option that still delivers on flavor.

Finally, consider how much time you have to prepare your sandwich. If you’re short on time, pre-sliced or shredded cheese might be more convenient than cutting up a block of cheese yourself. On the other hand, if you have more time to spare, slicing up your own cheese will provide maximum freshness and taste! No matter which type of cheese you choose for your turkey sandwich, taking these tips into consideration will help ensure it comes out delicious every time.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Types Of Bread Pair Best With A Turkey Sandwich?

Choosing the right bread for a turkey sandwich can be just as important as selecting the best cheese. After all, it’s the foundation of the sandwich and having a stale or dull piece of bread can completely ruin a meal. But on the other hand, finding the perfect bread to pair with turkey can really elevate your sandwich game.

When it comes to sandwiches, there are many types of bread out there to choose from. White or wheat slices are always classic options that pair well with most deli meats like turkey. For something slightly heartier, ciabatta rolls or focaccia have a nice crunch and chewiness that complements turkey nicely. If you’re looking for something healthier, whole-grain or oat breads are great alternatives that still provide plenty of flavor and texture.

There’s also no shortage of creative options when it comes to making an unforgettable sandwich. Sourdough and rye both offer unique tastes that really stand out when paired with turkey. Or if you’re feeling adventurous, try using pita pockets or flatbreads for a more international twist on your turkey sandwich. No matter which type you choose, adding some delicious cheese will take your sandwich from good to great!

Whichever type of bread you decide on for your turkey sandwich, make sure it complements both the meat and cheese you’ve chosen for the ultimate flavor experience! With so many different types available, there’s something for everyone – so don’t be afraid to get creative and experiment with different combinations until you find one that works perfectly for you!

How Can I Make A Healthier Version Of A Turkey Sandwich?

Making healthier versions of favorite sandwiches can be a challenge. But, with the right ingredients and combinations, it’s possible to enjoy a great-tasting turkey sandwich without sacrificing flavor or texture. So, how can you make a healthier version of a turkey sandwich?

First, look for leaner cuts of meat like sliced turkey breast. This will help to reduce the amount of fat and calories in the sandwich. Next, consider using whole grain bread instead of white bread. Whole grain bread is higher in fiber and other nutrients than white bread, making it a much better choice for a healthy sandwich.

Finally, load up your sandwich with fresh vegetables like lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers and peppers. These add crunch as well as vitamins and minerals to your meal. You can also add condiments like mustard or hummus for extra flavor. Adding these nutritious ingredients will not only make your sandwich more satisfying but it will also help you reach your daily nutrition goals.

In summary, there are several ways to make a healthier version of a turkey sandwich that won’t sacrifice taste or texture. By choosing leaner cuts of meat, whole grain bread and lots of fresh vegetables or condiments, you can create an enjoyable yet nutritious meal that everyone will love!

Are There Any Vegan Cheeses That Work Well In A Turkey Sandwich?

When it comes to making a healthier version of a turkey sandwich, many people may opt for vegan cheese instead of the traditional dairy-based option. But are there any vegan cheeses that are suitable for a turkey sandwich? The answer is yes! There are several different types of vegan cheese that can add flavor and texture to a delicious turkey sandwich.

The most popular type of vegan cheese for sandwiches is cashew cheese. It has a creamy, nutty flavor and is made from blended cashews, nutritional yeast, garlic powder, and lemon juice. Cashew cheese can be easily spread on bread or crackers to make a delicious and healthy sandwich with all the flavor of regular cheese without any animal products.

Another great vegan option for sandwiches is smoked tofu. Smoked tofu has a smoky flavor that works well in combination with the savory flavors of turkey and other toppings like lettuce, tomato, onion, or pickles. Smoked tofu is also high in protein and low in fat, making it an ideal choice for those looking to make their sandwich healthier.

Vegan cheeses like cashew cheese and smoked tofu are great options when crafting a healthier version of the classic turkey sandwich. They provide all the flavor of regular cheeses without any added dairy or animal products while still being full of protein and other essential nutrients that make them a nutritious addition to your meal.

What Other Toppings Can I Add To A Turkey Sandwich?

Topping a turkey sandwich can be a great way to create a delicious and filling meal. The possibilities for topping your sandwich are endless. From traditional condiments to more inventive options, here are some suggestions for creating the perfect turkey sandwich.

First, consider the basics. Mustard, mayonnaise, and ketchup are all classic additions that provide flavor and moisture to a turkey sandwich. They also pair nicely with other toppings like lettuce and tomato. Additionally, you can experiment with different types of mustard such as Dijon or honey mustard for added flavor.

Next, think about adding additional vegetables or fruits for texture and flavor. Sliced pickles or jalapenos add crunchy bites while diced onions or peppers bring in some spice. Avocado slices are also a great option if you’re looking for an extra boost of healthy fats and fiber. Alternatively, thinly sliced apples or pears can provide sweetness to the savory flavors of the turkey and cheese.

Finally, don’t forget about herbs! Fresh herbs like basil or cilantro are perfect for adding an extra layer of flavor to your sandwich without being too overwhelming. For even more zing, try sprinkling on some red pepper flakes before serving up your masterpiece! With these ingredients at your disposal, you’re sure to craft the ultimate turkey sandwich experience!

What Are Some Creative Ways To Dress Up A Turkey Sandwich?

When it comes to making a delicious turkey sandwich, the possibilities are endless. While cheese is certainly an important part of the equation, there are countless other ways to dress up your sandwich and make it truly unique. From adding flavorful sauces to incorporating different kinds of breads, here are some creative ways to enhance a classic turkey sandwich.

One great way to add flavor is by using condiments that you wouldn’t traditionally use on sandwiches. Try experimenting with things like horseradish or pesto for a zesty kick that will transform your turkey sandwich into something extraordinary. You can also mix together some freshly chopped herbs like cilantro or parsley for a bright, fresh taste. To take it one step further, try adding some pickled jalapenos for a hint of heat.

Finally, why not change up the type of bread you use? If you’re looking for something heartier and more substantial, opt for a sourdough loaf. For something lighter and sweeter, go for a whole wheat roll or even an English muffin. You can also switch out regular mayonnaise for something more unique such as tahini or hummus. With so many options available to you, transforming your turkey sandwich into something special is easier than ever!

It’s time to get creative in the kitchen and start building that perfect turkey sandwich! Whether you’re looking for extra flavor or just want to switch things up a bit, these tips will help you create an unforgettable meal that everyone in the family is sure to enjoy.

Want to know where to get your food supplies delivered, with a huge choice of good? Try Amazon Fresh 


In conclusion, a turkey sandwich is a delicious and versatile meal. To make the perfect sandwich, pair it with the right type of bread. Whole wheat or sourdough are both good options for a healthier version. When it comes to cheese, there are many choices such as cheddar, swiss, mozzarella, and even vegan varieties that all work well with a turkey sandwich. Toppings can range from classic lettuce and tomato to more creative add-ons like bacon, pickles, or onion rings. With so many possibilities, you’re sure to find the perfect combination of ingredients that will make your turkey sandwich one to remember!

After putting it to the test the Jack was my number 1 choice with the Swiss a close second!

I personally love adding some sliced avocado on top of my turkey sandwiches – it adds an extra layer of flavor and texture that really takes it up a notch. Of course, you can also dress up your sandwich with sauces like mayo or mustard for even more flavor. With all these amazing ingredients at your disposal, you can create a truly unique and delicious turkey sandwich in no time!

Last update on 2024-07-16 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API


About the Author


Leave a Comment:

All fields with “*” are required

Leave a Comment:

All fields with “*” are required